Reported for the third time, and the first two answers were wrong in the same
way: I treated "it should not be visible" as a number to reduce rather than a
rule to satisfy. The bench's through-tenons went 42 mm proud, then 3 mm, and
3 mm is still a raised patch with a lit edge on it — visible in the render,
and the thing being complained about. The market stall then reproduced it
exactly: four post heads through the awning, like tacks.
Both were pushed proud DELIBERATELY, to keep two faces out of one plane and
away from the z-fight check. That trade is false, and this is the sentence
worth keeping: a piece that must not show ends INSIDE the solid it enters. A
buried face cannot be coplanar with a surface and cannot be seen. Level with
the surface is the only genuinely bad option, and it was the one I kept
treating as the alternative.
- The bench's tenon is now housed an eighth of the seat's thickness below
the top. That is a real joint rather than a compromise: a stub tenon into
the underside of a board is how a bench is made when the top is thick
enough to take it, which at 0.135 of the height it is. What is lost is the
panel of end grain; what is gained is a seat.
- The stall's posts stop ON the cloth's mid surface, with half its thickness
over them, and the cloth went from 0.2 of a board to 0.42 so there is
something to bury them in. The heads now sit 25 mm under the top surface.
And the brief is a check now, because a rule I keep is worth less than a rule
the build keeps. `nothingAbove` names the part nothing else may rise above —
the seat, the counter, the awning — and it reports the offender and the
millimetres. Mutation-tested: pushing the tenon back to 3 mm proud fails it
with "PROUD: legs by 3.0mm".
38 models, all checks pass, 0 floating cases, documentation in step.
Reported twice. The first time I planed the through-tenons from 42 mm proud to
3 and called it done, which answered the tenons rather than the question — the
tenons were never it. Measured again now: nothing stands more than 3.9 mm above
the seat at any slider setting, and the thing that was catching was on the
LEGS.
The leg board widens on the way down; that is the splay. The two feet, cut out
of its bottom edge by the arch, were built at `footWidth` — the board's width
at the FLOOR. But a foot starts at the top of the arch, a third of the way up,
where the board has not widened that far yet. So every foot stood proud of the
board it hangs from, on both sides, as a hard shoulder at shin height: 14 mm by
default, 20 mm on a wide bench, 32 mm at full splay. Setting the splay to zero
made it vanish, which is what finally named the cause.
The leg's outer edge is a straight line from `footWidth / 2` at the floor to
`legWidth / 2` under the seat, and a foot's outer face has to lie ON that line
rather than run vertically up from its own base. A tapered box narrows about
its centre, so taking twice the taper off the top width moves the outer face in
by exactly the taper — and moves the inner face out by the same, narrowing the
arch as it rises, which is also what a splayed leg does. 14.2 mm becomes 0.2,
32.3 becomes 0.4, and 0.2 mm is the sampling resolution rather than a step.
`scripts/probe-bench.ts` is how it was found and it took two wrong versions to
get there, both failing the same way — by measuring something and reporting a
number that was not the answer:
- The first sampled vertices into height bands. A tapered box has corners
only at its top and bottom, so the bands between them came out empty, were
skipped, and it reported a confident 0.0 mm step for a leg with a 17 mm
shoulder on it. It now slices the actual triangles, which gives a width at
any height whether a corner is there or not.
- The second scanned the full height of the leg part and found its biggest
drop at 86% — exactly where the board ends and only the tenon carries on
into the seat. That is what a tenon IS. A real fault of 14 mm was sitting
underneath a 66 mm reading that was not a fault at all, so the scan now
stops at the seat's underside.
Both media images regenerated, since the bench is in each of them.
Three defects reported from looking at the models, and the first of them
says something about the check that was supposed to catch it.
Every third coin was lifted to "land on top of the previous one" while its
position stayed independently scattered, so it was almost never above
anything and simply hovered about 3 mm off the ground. A stacking coin now
takes the previous coin's PLACE as well as its height. The tilted ones were
lifted by half their thickness plus their circumradius; a coin is a
nine-sided prism and can come to rest on a face rather than a corner, so
the lift uses the apothem and its own radius, erring towards bedding into
the ground rather than floating above it.
The support check missed all of that, and the reason is worth writing down:
its voxel is the model's extent over the resolution, so at 64 a 0.19 m coin
pouch gets a 3 mm voxel -- exactly the size of the gap it existed to find. A
check coarser than the defect it hunts is worth very little. At 112 the
whole suite still runs in fifteen seconds.
Raising it immediately turned up a real fault nobody had seen. The log
pile's sawn ends were cut to exactly the body's end radius and placed
exactly at its rim, so disc and lathe met along a seam of no width: they
touched and never overlapped, and there was nothing joining them but two
edges in the same place. The caps are now three percent wider and seated
slightly inside, which is two millimetres here and true of a real log
anyway, since bark wears back from a cut face.
And the bench's through-tenons stood 42 mm proud of the seat -- a block of
oak the size of a thumb sticking straight up out of the surface you are
meant to sit on. A real through-tenon is wedged and then planed back, so
what shows is end grain and a hairline of shoulder. Three millimetres
proud, ten housed below.
28 models, 20 547 triangles, all checks pass at resolution 112, 0 floating
cases, build clean.
Across the contact sheet several pieces read as flimsy, and I called that
systemic before measuring it. Measured, it is two models out of three.
The bench seat was height * 0.09, which is 40 mm on a bench 1.62 m long --
one fortieth of its own span, against roughly one twentieth in the
reference. The table top was height * 0.045, a 33 mm plank across 1.9 m.
Both are now about half again as thick. Medieval furniture is riven rather
than machined: the board is whatever the log gave, and a thin slab over a
long span also looks like it would flex, which is the specific way these
were reading as cheap.
The fence, which looked as thin as either, measures fine -- 150 mm posts
on a 1.25 m fence. What made it look spindly is that the default is 4.8 m
long, so the whole run gets scaled down to fit the frame while the
reference shows a single short section. That is a framing artefact, not a
defect, and nothing about the fence changes here.
The bench also gets the arch cut out of its feet. It is not decoration: a
plank leg standing on its whole edge rocks on any floor that is not flat,
and no medieval floor was, so the cut leaves two feet per board and gives
the bench four points to find the ground with. It is also the most
recognisable line in the silhouette and the reference has it. There are no
booleans in this geometry -- it is all non-indexed triangle soup -- so the
notch is made by building the board in three pieces and not filling it.
27 models, 18647 triangles, all checks pass, 0 floating cases, build clean.
The kit is going public, so everything a reader sees is now English:
27 model sources, the core vocabulary, meta.ts (titles, descriptions and
every slider label), the viewer UI, all script output, REFERENCE.md and
the READMEs.
Rules applied: only comments, doc comments and human-facing strings were
touched. Identifiers, numbers, logic, registry item ids, part names and
material slot names are unchanged — those are a published contract and
were already English.
Verified rather than assumed: for all 53 changed .ts files the code
skeleton (source with comments stripped and string contents replaced by a
placeholder) is byte-identical before and after. Full gate is green —
typecheck, registry conformance, ~510 model checks, GLB round trip and a
production build.
Also fixed here:
- index.html and viewer.html were missed by the translation pass because
the file list only covered .ts/.md/.css. Both had lang="tr" and Turkish
titles.
- The viewer formatted triangle counts with toLocaleString('tr-TR'), which
prints 15.425 rather than 15,425.
- REFERENCE.md's model table header did not match what
scripts/catalog-table.ts emits, so the next regeneration would have
silently changed it. Aligned to the generator.
- Removed scripts/probe.ts and scripts/zdiag.ts; they were throwaway
diagnostics that got committed by accident.
Modeller (13 → 26): chest, bench, torch, lantern, bell, sign, hay bale,
sack, broom, tankard, book, phial, coin pouch. Kürek, çapa ve yaba
render'lara bakılarak yeniden yazıldı.
core:
- createKitModel artık tipli `actions` ve `update(dt)` taşıyor
- BuiltPart.extras: bir parça birden çok materyal yuvası kullanabiliyor
(sandığın kapağı = meşe tahta + demir kayış, birlikte dönmek zorunda)
- BuiltPart.origin: parça başına dönme merkezi (menteşe, sarkaç)
- bendGeometry / roughenGeometry / mottleGeometry
- 5 yeni materyal yuvası: steel, brass, straw, cloth, leather, glass
- bandGeometry({ inner }) — serbest halkalar kapalı katı olabilsin
my-registry/meta.ts: katalog metadata'sı artık build.ts ve viewer için
tek kaynak. Doğrulama modelle metadata'nın uyuştuğunu denetliyor ve bu
eklendiği gün dört modelde gerçek bir sapma yakaladı.
Doğrulama (~500 kontrol):
- metadata uyumu, eylem semantiği, kare hızı bağımsızlığı
- scripts/render.ts: tarayıcısız yazılım rasterleyici. Bütün doğrulama
geometrikti; "bu kürek küreğe benzemiyor" diyebilmek için modele
bakmak gerekiyordu
- scripts/verify-glb.ts: dışa aktar → geri oku → karşılaştır
GLB dışa aktarımı: viewer düğmesi ve toplu CLI aynı kodu kullanıyor.
Viewer:
- parça paneli (solo/izole) ve materyal yuvası paneli (canlı renk override)
- kit görünümü: 26 model tek sahnede, ölçek ve ton tutarlılığı için
- configure() sonrası gölge bayraklarının düşmesi düzeltildi
